Two users, one Docker socket
Test permissions as the user that will run the command
Group membership does not apply to an already-running process.
Jenkins runs as its own system user. The permission that matters is the jenkins user's, not yours.
Test it the way Jenkins will:
sudo -u jenkins docker ps
If that fails with a socket permission error:
sudo usermod -aG docker jenkins
sudo systemctl restart jenkins
The restart is required. A running process does not pick up new group membership, which is why the fix often looks like it did not work.
Takeaway
sudo -u is the difference between testing your own access and testing the access that actually matters.